No doubt, both the Cuisinart ICE-30BC and the Cuisinart ICE 45 are among the best ice cream makers in the market today. To choose a good ice cream maker, some of the factors to consider are the warranty, weight, material, convenience, bowl capacity, freezing speed, freezing method, versatility, and operation principle.
When these yardsticks were used to evaluate ice cream makers, two ice cream maker models came up among the very best. Now, the next question that will be on your mind is which of them do you go for? Honestly, there is no direct answer to that. They are both great products, and they both have their superior benefits and drawbacks. So, it is better to outline their features for you to decide which one to go for. Both Cuisinart ICE-30 and ICE-45 have been compared below feature by feature.
Operation Principle
ICE-30
This ice maker offers semi-automatic operation since not every part of its operation is automatic. However, some function can be operated manually.
ICE-45
Just like the Cuisinart ICE-30, the operation of this model is semi-automatic.
When it comes to the operation, neither one of the ice cream makers the others. Well, if you prefer a fully automatic ice cream maker, you can go for other ice cream models. However, you need to bear one thing in mind. It is very difficult to get a single model of ice cream maker with all your preferred features. You may need to prioritize some of the features.
What they are used for
ICE-30
This model can be used to prepare ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, gelato, and frozen beverages.
ICE-45
Just like ICE-30, this model can also be used to prepare ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, gelato, and frozen beverages.
While a lot of people believe that a compressor freezer has a significant advantage over a freezer bowl because the former makes it easier to make ice cream in batches, we argue that the advantage can be countered by making use of multiple freezer bowls.
Freezing speed
ICE-30
It takes this model about 20 to 25 minutes to freeze ice cream when its bowl is filled.
ICE-45
It takes this model the same amount of time to freeze ice cream when its bowl is filled.
The speed of an ice cream maker cannot be considered on its own without its bowl capacity. Although they have the same freezing rate, the fact that the Cuisinart ICE-30 has a more significant bowl capacity makes a big difference. The difference in their speed/bowl capacity may not be noticeable when you are preparing a tiny quantity of ice cream, but it will be more evident when you are making a tremendous amount of ice cream.
Bowl Capacity
ICE-30
The bowl capacity of this model is 2 quarts. It is slightly more significant than that of ICE-45.
ICE-45
The bowl capacity of this model is 1½ quart.
As mentioned earlier, the difference in bowl capacities will affect the speed of making ice cream. If you intend to prepare 6 quarts of ice cream, the Cuisinart ICE-30 will do that in 60 minutes (20 minutes x 3). On the other hand, the Cuisinart ICE-45 will make the same amount of ice cream in 80 minutes (20 minutes x 4).
How convenient are they
ICE-30
This model is very convenient to use. It comes with a rubber bottom that prevents it from shifting when it is accidentally pushed. This model also comes with cord storage and an easy to lock lid. Also, its cover is transparent so you can see through it while your ice cream is in the making.
ICE-45
Instead of a being transparent, the lid on the Cuisinart ICE-45 has a window. It also has an easy to use the dispensing bracket with a handle.
While both of them are quite convenient, it is clear that the ICE-45 offers more convenience here. So, regarding practicality, you can choose the ICE-45 over the ICE-30. However, ICE-30’s bigger freezer bowl is a good trade-off.
Their material
ICE-30
This ice cream maker is made of brushed metal, a double insulated stainless steel bowl, and a lid made of plastic.
ICE-45
This model is made of plastic. It has a removable stainless steel bowl and plastic containers.
There is not much to say about the material since both of them have proved their durability over the years.
Cuisinart ICE-30 vs ICE-45: Conclusion
Conclusively, considering the comparisons above, we think that it is clear that the Cuisinart ICE-30 ice cream maker is the better choice. However, the price could be another trade-off. If the ICE-30 is more expensive than the ICE-45, then it becomes a matter of personal preference.